Skip to main content
Main content
Caregiving

After 2 deaths, grand jury finds ‘dysfunction’ and ‘failures’ at Allegheny County elder protection agency

by Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA |

Illustration of an older person looking outside a window as days tick go by.
Daniel Fishel / For Spotlight PA

HARRISBURG — A new and searing grand jury report has revealed systemic flaws and inadequacies within one of the largest agencies in Pennsylvania tasked with investigating abuse and neglect allegations involving the state’s most vulnerable older adults.

The 43-page report released by Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr.’s office on Wednesday described in raw and unsparing detail how a lack of training and other problems at the county’s aging agency failed an elderly couple at risk of severe and persistent neglect — with fatal consequences.

”Findings within the report cite several instances where [the county aging agency] or its subcontractors failed to appropriately intervene in matters, ultimately leading to the deaths of an elderly couple,” Zappala’s office said in a news release announcing the report, which it said reveals “major systemic issues.”

In releasing the report, Zappala’s office provided a rare glimpse into the devastating consequences for older adults when the state’s social safety network falls short. That system, which Spotlight PA has investigated in its yearslong “Unprotected” series, is plagued by deep-seated deficiencies that have long been shielded from public scrutiny.

The grand jury report described “patterns of dysfunction” within the Allegheny County agency and multiple “failures.” Some of the findings echo problems Spotlight PA reporting has revealed, most notably delays in timely and efficiently investigating abuse and neglect cases, some of which have remained open for months, and even a year or more. State regulations require abuse and neglect cases to be investigated within 20 days. That timeline includes providing protective services if allegations are substantiated.

The Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office is among the growing number of independent agencies that have recently committed to highlighting these issues. Some have used their investigative powers to rip the system's veil of secrecy.

Despite this, the Shapiro administration has taken the position that though there is room for improvement in how counties keep older adults safe from abuse and neglect, there is no crisis. In fact, the administration’s Department of Aging recently took the rare step of loudly rejecting a top state watchdog’s audit that found oversight of county aging agencies is riddled with weaknesses and could be leaving older adults at risk of further harm.

Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro has also refused to release the findings of a separate report by the state inspector general’s office on the department's oversight of county aging agencies. Shapiro has claimed such reports are confidential, even though he has discretion to publicly release information in them. Former Democratic Gov. Tom. Wolf, for instance, released several inspector general reports or summaries, including one in 2018 on a nearly identical topic: the state of Pennsylvania’s older adult protective services.

A state aging department spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Zappala’s grand jury report. The Department of Aging is led by Secretary Jason Kavulich, a onetime county aging agency director who was appointed to the statewide post by Shapiro in 2023. His department funds and monitors the state’s 52 county aging agencies, including Allegheny’s. Those 52 agencies cover all 67 counties.

In an email, Allegheny County’s solicitor, Rosalyn Guy-McCorkle, said she would not elaborate on the report’s findings, citing what she called the “ongoing criminal investigation” by Zappala’s office. The grand jury report noted the inquiry was focused on the failures of government agencies, rather than whether any criminal charges are warranted in the elder couple’s deaths.

Guy-McCorkle did say that the county aging agency has already taken steps to address recommendations for improvement included in the report.

“Every Allegheny County resident deserves to be treated with dignity and care, especially our older adult population,” Guy-McCorkle wrote. “These changes reflect our commitment to strengthening oversight, improving accountability, and protecting older adults.”

This story will be updated.