New to voting in PA or need a refresher? Visit our Election Center 2024 »
Skip to main content
Main content

PA families scramble to find child care

Plus, how hospitals like UPMC retain "nonprofit" status despite vast business holdings

How We Care is presented by Spotlight PA. Support this vital journalism by clicking here.

This week: Structural issues remain in Pa. child care, why nonprofit hospitals make lots of money, and a fudge company employs people with disabilities.

Two children play in a sandbox at a Pittsburgh daycare

Children at Shady Lane School in Pittsburgh play in a sandbox. (Commonwealth Media Services)

HELP WANTED

When Carli Viola-Luqa learned in April that her kid's child care facility planned to permanently close, she panicked.


Viola-Luqa, a nurse, and her husband, a dentist, both work full time and have no family in Pennsylvania.


The couple, who live in suburban Pittsburgh, had depended on the early childhood center for more than 45 hours of care per week. While Viola-Luqa scrambled to find a new program with openings for her two toddlers, she teamed up with another mom to split caregiving duties and also hired a part-time nanny.


This temporary fix was not ideal. Viola-Luqa had to ask for a lot of flexibility from her job, which she started less than a year ago. She worried that her frequent requests for time off and the weird hours she was working reflected poorly on her as a new employee.


Viola-Luqa started having trouble sleeping and even considered sending her small children to stay with their grandparents in Canada until she found a permanent solution.


“I had tunnel vision. I felt like I couldn’t even make rational decisions. I was just being reactive,” Viola-Luqa said.


Many parents across Pennsylvania face similar predicaments. There simply aren’t enough child care providers, and advocates say the situation will get worse without help from the state.


Diane Barber, executive director of the Pennsylvania Child Care Association, said she knows of seven early childhood programs that have either closed or announced  closures to come in the past month.


“We can open more child care, but there’s a reason those programs closed. Because

they couldn’t do it anymore. Because they couldn’t afford to do it anymore,” Barber said.


The problem, experts told Spotlight PA, is largely low wages, which make it difficult for child care programs to hire and retain staff. A May 2023 report from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics found the mean annual income for a child care worker in Pennsylvania is $29,480, less than half of the mean wage for workers overall. For a preschool teacher, it’s $36,350.


As Viola-Luqa can attest, parents who lack child care can’t punch the clock. The business community says this issue significantly contributes to the workforce shortage.


In June, a coalition of more than 50 local chambers of commerce penned an open letter urging lawmakers to fund child care programs directly: “Providers just can’t compete in a labor market with many sectors offering $20+ per hour for largely unskilled positions.”


The business chambers also joined forces with child care advocates to campaign for a $284 million infusion of new and recurring state dollars, arguing the money would allow providers to increase workforce recruitment and retention efforts.


Despite the state’s $10.6 billion budget surplus, this push failed.


“We are very disappointed,” said Jen DeBell, the executive director of the Pennsylvania Association for the Education of Young Children.


Read the full story here.


Sarah Boden, for Spotlight PA


Reader Resources

UPMC Pinnacle is pictured in 2020

Former hospital UPMC Pinnacle pictured in 2020. (Blaine Shahan / LNP)

Must-Read

‘ROLLING IN MONEY’: Nonprofit hospitals such as UPMC “have somehow managed to keep myriad for-profit enterprises under their nonprofit umbrella — a status that means they pay little or no taxes, float bonds at preferred rates, and gain numerous other financial advantages,” reports KFF. Full story →

Big Stories

TONGUE-TIE: “Tongue-tie — a condition in infants that can affect breastfeeding — may be overdiagnosed in the U.S. and too often treated with unnecessary surgery,” reports the Associated Press. Full story →

WOUND WORRIES: Rachel McFadden, an emergency room nurse at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, details how the stigma surrounding xylazine wounds prevents people from getting medical care, via The Conversation. Full story →

The Upside

BETTER FOOD: “Oasis Farm & Fishery is working to improve the healthy eating habits of elementary school children in Homewood through their Better Food, Better Me (BFBM) food education program,” reports Pittsburgh City Paper. Full story →

SWEET GIG: “Spectrum Fudge works with the Pennsylvania Office of Vocational Rehabilitation and eight local school districts to help people with developmental disabilities earn a paycheck,” reports the Pittsburgh Union Progress. Full story →

Talk to Us


We want to hear your feedback on what’s working in this newsletter, what’s missing, and how we can make it the most useful weekly touchpoint it can be.


Send comments, story tips, and more to newsletters@spotlightpa.org.

Like this newsletter? Share it with a friend

Forwarded this newsletter? Subscribe here

Interested in sponsorship? Email membership@spotlightpa.org