Did you know Spotlight PA is a nonprofit? Learn more about our nonpartisan journalism »
Skip to main content
Main content

Are officials' social media posts public records?

Plus: State College Pride names Malcolm Kenyatta grand marshal

This is Talk of the Town, a free weekly newsletter delivering top news from State College and the surrounding region.

May 18, 2023
Support local investigative journalism! If each Talk of the Town subscriber gives just $15/month, we will meet our fundraising goal for Spotlight PA’s State College bureau this year! Contribute now. As a special bonus, all gifts made today will be DOUBLED by the Lenfest Institute for Journalism as part of our Spring Member Drive. 🌸
Inside this edition: Election results, Malcolm Kenyatta chosen as State College Pride grand marshal, and determining whether elected officials’ social media posts are public records.
Dan Nott / For Spotlight PA
How Local Government Works is a series that focuses on issues and trends in Pennsylvania local governments and provides tools for readers to hold their local officials accountable.

A recent court decision raised the bar for when a government official’s personal social media posts are public records, and will likely make it more burdensome and costly for Pennsylvanians to get their hands on this information.  

In an April opinion, Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court established a three-factor test to judge when social media posts made on public officials’ personal accounts should be accessible under the Right-to-Know Law.

Government agencies, the Office of Open Records, and the courts have the power to decide what records should be provided to the public. The test guides them to first examine the social media account in question, including its private or public status, its appearance or purpose, and any actual or apparent duty for public officials to operate it. 

The court said agencies that receive open-records requests also should consider the contents of the account, if they “prove, support, or evidence a transaction or activity of an agency.” 

The third factor to weigh is whether the person operating the account is acting in what the court calls their “official capacity.” Commonwealth Court cited a previous opinion that found a York Township commissioner’s emails on a personal computer weren’t public records because the township didn’t ratify, adopt, or confirm what the emails discussed.

“This is such a significant opinion because it is, in my opinion, a change of the law as it's been developing,” Josh Bonn, an attorney practicing in open records and municipal law, told Spotlight PA. 

A generally accepted interpretation prior to the April decision was that anytime a public official communicates about public business, “that’s presumed to be a public record.” Bonn said he felt the weight given to the official capacity factor in the court’s newly minted test was a departure from that rule of thumb. 

The Office of Open Records — an independent agency that handles disputes over public record requests — had previously ruled that the contents of a social media account decide if they should be public records, and whether a government agency authorizes or controls those accounts was “immaterial” to the question.

All three factors should be assessed in a nonexclusive manner, the opinion said, meaning the agency or court tasked with deciding a record request can determine on a case-by-case basis how much weight each of the elements should carry. Legal experts said that leaves a lot of room for argument, and more litigation on this issue is likely on the horizon. 

“There can be a lot of different permutations of how these accounts can be used, and this test allows those different permutations to be reviewed,” Bonn said. He added that Commonwealth Court performed a detailed analysis of relevant case laws in its opinion, and the matter is far from settled. 

Courts and government officials nationwide are trying to determine the boundaries between official and personal speech on social media. Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas acknowledged in the opinion that it’s an evolving legal issue, writing “this Court’s precedents are in apparent tension.”

“It will be important for agencies to remember that when in doubt, they should err on the side of openness because the [Right-to-Know] law favors access,” said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association, of which Spotlight PA is a member. 

“Social media often provides an unfiltered window into public officials’ stance on important issues, and the public has a right to know where their elected officials stand,” she said.

Have a question about your local government? Email Min Xian at mxian@spotlightpa.org

Min Xian, Local Accountability Reporter
“One of the answers is [for local governments] to get together with their neighbors to help taxpayers afford those services. The great thing about this [program] is the state is encouraging the conversation.”

—John Brenner, executive director for the Pennsylvania Municipal League, told Spotlight PA of the potential 266% funding increase for the state Municipal Assistance Program
» Proposed Pa. budget nearly quadruples funding for local government cooperation

» Pa. health department faces lawmaker questioning over medical marijuana doctor data

» Pa. election results: Carluccio, McCaffery win Supreme Court primary, will advance to November general

» Pa. opioid settlement money: What you need to know

» POLICING VS TREATMENT: Join us Thursday, May 25 at 6 pm ET for a free panel on how Pa. wants to spend a $1B opioid settlement, the policing versus treatment debate, and how Pennsylvania’s spending plans compare to other states’. Register here and submit questions to events@spotlightpa.org 
Clinton County’s Hyner View State Park on a rainy day, captured by Dave Nolte | Prime Shots.

Want to be featured here? Send your best local pics to talkofthetown@spotlightpa.org.
💕 Love Talk of the Town? Help us keep growing by sharing this newsletter with your friends! Did someone forward this email to you? Click here to sign up.
» CDT: Election results for Centre County races
» Mirror: Mining project concerns Hollidaysburg residents
» Courier Express: Sandy Twp. to ask for stay in DuBois consolidation

» CDT: State College Pride picks Malcolm Kenyatta for grand marshal
» Cove Herald: Roaring Spring fire officials say tax increase is vital
Want us to list your event? Send it to us.

» May 18-19: Lewis & Clark Circus is stopping by the Tioga County Fairgrounds.

» May 18-21: Have a laugh at the second annual Happy Valley XL Improv Festival in State College.

» May 20: The Cameron County Mud Run — featuring trucks, SUVs, and Jeeps — is back for the third year.

» May 20: The We Care Foundation presents its 10th annual Spring Blues and Brews event at Lakemont Park in Altoona, featuring live music and beer and wine tastings.

» May 20: Browse more than 5,000 plants at the Centre County Master Gardeners Plant Sale, held at the Ag Progress Days Site.

» May 21: Learn more about recreation opportunities at the Outdoor Adventure Expo in Bellefonte.
An anagram is a word, phrase, or name formed by rearranging the letters of another. For example, “spotlight” also forms “stoplight.”

Decode the anagram and send your answer to talkofthetown@spotlightpa.org. We’ll shout out winners here, and one each week will get some Spotlight PA State College swag.

Good luck!

Last week’s answer: Outside

Congrats to Jon W.
, who will receive Spotlight PA State College swag. Others who answered correctly: Don H., Mike Z., Tish M., and Donna D.
Do you have events, community shoutouts, questions about our region, or tips on stories that we should pursue? Email our team.
Love north-central Pennsylvania? Subscribe to Talk of the Town!

Have a friend who would like our work? Share our newsletter!

Our State College bureau depends on your support.

Help us power investigative journalism in our communities that gets results by becoming a member now & during our Spring Member Drive, your gift will be DOUBLED.

Spotlight PA is an independent, non-partisan newsroom powered by The Philadelphia Inquirer in partnership with PennLive/The Patriot-News, TribLIVE/Pittsburgh Tribune-Review and WITF Public Media.

Copyright © Spotlight PA / The Philadelphia Inquirer, All rights reserved.

Spotlight PA
228 Walnut St., #11728
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1728


You're receiving this email because you've subscribed to updates from our State College regional bureau covering North-Central PA.

This email was sent to: <<Email Address>>

Receiving too many emails from Spotlight PA?

To change your newsletter subscriptions and frequency, you can update your preferences.

To stop receiving fundraising messages, you can update your preferences and select "Opt out of Fundraising."

To stop receiving ALL EMAILS from Spotlight PA, including all of our investigations and newsletters, you can completely unsubscribe here.