Did you know Spotlight PA is a nonprofit? Learn more about our nonpartisan journalism »
Skip to main content
Main content

Five takeaways from our property tax event

Plus: State budget fights, card swipe fees, and a lawsuit over voter data

This is Talk of the Town, a free weekly newsletter delivering top news from State College and the surrounding region.

June 27, 2024
Inside this edition: Takeaways from our property tax event, education funding holds up a budget deal, and Spotlight PA's plans for a Berks County bureau.
Property taxes are a critical source of revenue for Pennsylvania municipalities and school districts, but political inertia and fear of rising costs can prevent communities from keeping rates updated.

The taxes are determined by assessments, which dictate how much a property is worth and shape how much property owners must pay.

So when assessments are outdated, funding for schools, roads, and other essential services potentially falls short. Local leaders have the ability to adjust taxes and ensure assessments happen regularly, but because such tweaks can raise costs for constituents, the issue is touchy. Some officials have been voted out following changes.

Spotlight PA Local Accountability Reporter Min Xian spoke with a panel of experts about outdated assessments and how they affect Pennsylvanians.

Here are five key takeaways from the discussion, which can be viewed in full here.

Property taxes are the lifeblood of local government.

Property taxes are calculated by multiplying the assessed value of a home or piece of real estate with the tax rates — also known as millages —set by county governments, local municipalities, and school districts. 

Each year, those bodies come up with budgets and decide how much revenue they need to provide essential functions like public education, police, and human services. They also set their own tax rates and rely heavily on property tax as a steady source of income.

Outdated assessments flout the tax uniformity rule. 

Counties conduct assessments, which serve as the basis for different property taxes levied by various levels of government. The Pennsylvania Constitution requires that taxes be uniform, meaning the tax burden must be equitably shared among residents.

When counties have uneven taxes, they can be taken to court. A 2009 Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision determined that the use of an outdated assessment in Allegheny County to establish the tax liability for a property violates the uniformity clause of the Pennsylvania Constitution. Allegheny underwent a countywide reassessment following the outcome of the case. The next year, the county's overall assessed value increased while tax rates went down.

Counties differ in population, property types, and market values, so the threshold for when a property reassessment is necessary varies geographically, said Lisa Schaefer, executive director for the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania. 

In a housing market that has remained relatively unchanged, an older assessment does not necessarily mean it’s less fair, she added. Without a mandate for regular assessments, counties make their own decisions about when updates are needed.  

Some counties are way behind on updating property values.

Property reassessments are politically unpopular and can cost a lot of money if they haven’t been done in decades. 

Lackawanna County commissioners voted in 2022 to reassess properties, something it had not done in 54 years, County Assessor Patrick Tobin said. 

The county was facing litigation over outdated property values, and Tobin said that it was “painfully obvious” a reassessment was needed, but the monetary and political costs were steep.

The ongoing reassessment has a price tag of over $5 million.

Tobin argued the decision will pay off over time. “If we wait 54 years again, it's going to cost a hell of a lot more than $5 million. But if we keep up with it, it's going to, in the long run, save taxpayers money,” he said.

The political price of the move has already been paid: The two county commissioners who voted to initiate the revalue were not reelected.

Individual assessment disputes deepen tax disparities.

Counties are the first place property owners go if they dispute the assessed value of their property. Eric Montarti, research director for the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy, estimated that seven to eight thousand appeals take place in Allegheny County each year. Across Pennsylvania, many disputes are decided by the courts. 

But individual adjustments don’t address wider uniformity issues. In fact, they can worsen existing disparities. In April, Pittsburgh Public Schools sued Allegheny County to force a countywide reassessment, citing the potential to lose millions in tax revenue over assessment disputes.

The state legislature could step in, but it hasn’t so far.

The possibility of an increased tax bill or a lower home value turns some taxpayers away from embracing assessments, even though they could benefit from higher overall housing value and income in the region. Knowing this, elected leaders tend to shy away from the issue to protect their political careers. State Sen. Wayne Fontana (D. Allegheny) said that’s why he believes lawmakers should mandate reassessments on a scheduled basis and take politics out of the question.

“I still have to go convince everyone in the Senate and the General Assembly to get enough votes,” Fontana said. “It's a long shot.”

Min Xian, Spotlight PA State College
Spotlight PA's special light-roast coffee, Headline Brews. Order yours today.
Spotlight PA’s special light roast coffee, “Headline Brews,” is available for pre-order for the first time.

Start your day with Spotlight PA and help brew a brighter, more informed Pennsylvania. Pairs perfectly with the exclusive Spotlight PA mug + all proceeds benefit our journalism.

Shop the store now »

» A bill quickly moving through the state House would reduce credit card "swipe fees," but faces tough odds in the Senate. 

» A far-right group is suing Pennsylvania to clean up its voting rolls. But experts say the group's claims reflect a "gross misunderstanding of election law." 

» Deciding how much to spend on K-12 education remains a key obstacle to closing a budget deal for state lawmakers.

» Colleges would face financial punishments for boycotting or divesting from Israel under new Pa. bill

» Spotlight PA plans to launch a Berks County bureau after seeing demand from residents for more local government scrutiny
How We Care illustration
Daniel Fishel / For Spotlight PA
Spotlight PA launched a new weekly newsletter focused on caregiving and caregivers across Pennsylvania. Every Tuesday, “How We Care” features original reporting and perspectives on how we care for one another at all stages of life, the huge economic and policy questions ahead, and how it’s affecting the lives of millions of people across the state. You can sign up for How We Care here.
A throwback photo of Pattee and Paterno Library at Penn State’s University Park campus in State College, via reporter Min Xian

Have a north-central Pennsylvania photo to share? Send it to us by email, use #PAGems on Instagram, or tag us @spotlightpennsylvania.
» CDT: Microburst winds damaged trees, buildings near Milesburg
» CDT: Would a regional approach make sense for Centre County police?
» NCP: Geisinger announces massive patient data breach
» SG: Big upgrades coming to Williamsport parks

» SC: Penn State hospital wants to vacate $5.25M awarded to doctor
Want us to list your event? Send it to us.

» June 27: Learn about women’s history in Huntingdon County on a walking tour.

» June 27-30: Enjoy a weekend of American roots music at Remington Ryde Bluegrass Festival at Grange Park in Centre County.

» June 28-29: Union County Veterans’ 4th of July Celebration, held in Lewisburg, features a fireworks show and gala parade.

» June 29: Experience the “ultimate taste combination” at the Bacon & Bourbon Fest at the Jaffa Shrine Center in Blair County.

» July 3: Attend the fireworks celebration in St. Marys, Elk County, which also includes activities and live music.
An anagram is a word, phrase, or name formed by rearranging the letters of another. For example, “spotlight” also forms “stoplight.”

Decode the anagram and send your answer to talkofthetown@spotlightpa.org. We’ll shout out winners here, and one each week will get some Spotlight PA State College swag.

Good luck!

Last week’s answer: Eternity

There were no new winners this week.

Send this newsletter to your friends so they get a shot at receiving Spotlight PA State College swag.

Those who answered correctly: Kevin M., Don H., Bill L., Frederick H.
Do you have events, community shoutouts, questions about our region, or tips on stories that we should pursue? Email our team.
Love north-central Pennsylvania? Subscribe to Talk of the Town!

Have a friend who would like our work? Share our newsletter!

Our State College bureau depends on your support.

Help us power investigative journalism in our communities that gets results by becoming a member now.

Spotlight PA is an independent, nonpartisan & nonprofit newsroom producing investigative and public-service journalism that holds the powerful to account and drives positive change in Pennsylvania.

Copyright © Spotlight PA. All rights reserved.

Spotlight PA
PO Box 11728
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1728


You’re receiving this email because you’ve subscribed to updates from our State College regional bureau covering North-Central PA.

This email was sent to: <<Email Address>>

Receiving too many emails from Spotlight PA?

To change your newsletter subscriptions and frequency, you can update your preferences.

To stop receiving fundraising messages, you can update your preferences and select “Opt out of Fundraising.”

To stop receiving ALL EMAILS from Spotlight PA, including all of our investigations and newsletters, you can completely unsubscribe here.